Hot Takes: Second Chances
Honest disagreement about second chances sets up Jonah’s uncomfortable reaction to mercy.
- Everyone stands in the middle. Say: “Walk to AGREE or DISAGREE. No names, no real stories, just what you think.”
- Read, one at a time: “Some people don’t deserve a second chance.” “If someone bullied you, it’s okay to hope they never change.” “Once someone gets called out online, they should stay canceled.” “You should forgive someone even if they never apologize.”
- After each, ask one person from each side for a one-sentence reason.
- SAY“Today’s prophet agreed with some of you. He thought his enemies didn’t deserve a second chance, so he ran from God to make sure they wouldn’t get one.”
Class screen: 🔥🗳️ Hot take: some people don’t deserve a second chance · Agree or disagree? · No names. Just what you think.
No supplies? Do this instead
Instead of: Two sheets of paper and a marker for AGREE and DISAGREE signs
- Everyone stands in the middle. Point to one wall: “AGREE.” Point to the other: “DISAGREE.” Say: “No names, no real stories, just what you think.”
- Read, one at a time: “Some people don’t deserve a second chance.” “If someone bullied you, it’s okay to hope they never change.” “Once someone gets called out online, they should stay canceled.” “You should forgive someone even if they never apologize.”
- After each, ask one person from each side for a one-sentence reason.
- SAY“Today’s prophet agreed with some of you. He thought his enemies didn’t deserve a second chance, so he ran from God to make sure they wouldn’t get one.”